/mg/ - Monster Girls

Main monster girl board

Mode: Reply
Name
Subject
Message

Max message length: 20000

Files

Max file size: 30.00 MB

Max files: 5

E-mail
Password

(used to delete files and postings)

Misc

Remember to follow the rules

[ Return / Catalog / Bottom ]

Sorter and Tier list for MGE Anonymous 04/20/2025 (Sun) 02:52:00 No. 16067
Blatantly copying a thread from Smug. Because its fun! Sorter: https://kikasuru.github.io/mge-charasort/ Tier list(slightly out of date): https://tiermaker.com/create/mge-344539 Doing the whole sorter takes like an hour (1000+ choices) so take your time, or limit the species. But doing the whole thing gets more fun the deeper you go. Its also neat seeing the end result and ponder your taste in context of it.
(1.04 MB 1024x1024 headcannon.png)
(881.65 KB 1568x1792 sort-2025-04-20(20_46_33).png)
...please don't ban me for the bottom ranking. Well, at least now i know for sure i like the softer types
>>16271 >The "one of two" sort is retarded to begin with, tiermaker get a ranking with like 100 clicks instead of 1000. It may take 1000 clicks, but I much prefer it because it sorts in a more objective way. I also don't like dragging hundreds of pictures into boxes, especially because most of them would end up in "meh" tier anyway. >>16295 >...please don't ban me for the bottom ranking. >doesn't show bottom ranks Interesting strats...
>>16282 Well played. >>16300 Agreed that the tiermaker drag is not ideal, much faster if it dumped all girls into the 'meh' tier and after that was "select a tier and then click girls to throw them in it". But that's a UI problem, I'll still defend it as more objective than the 1v1s because you get the final say no matter what. The problem with 1v1s is that even with 1000 choices the tool is still giving you a random subset of the ~20,000 total matchups, and the early rounds are given more weight in this because of how it sorts up or down. If your theoretical third favorite girl comes up against #1 and #2 in those rounds she usually ends up in more like #16 because the tiebreakers can only do so much. It's not likely to be that bad, but the birthday paradox means you're pretty likely to get notable skew, so that while your top 5 might be constant, even your top 20 would differ if you ran it twice. If you don't care about most girls, you also waste maybe 800 of those clicks unless you filter at the start, and if you keep them in for completeness it's probably not great for objectivity in the middle of the pack. Like for me personally, I would not object to a catgirl waifu of most sorts, but Jinko vs. Ocelomeh is so similar that my vote might go either way depending on what else I'm doing, or just non-canon stuff like having seen a nice Jinko greentext more recently. Though I admit even the statistics come out much better if you filter aggressively at the start.
>Interesting strats... ...i only noticed that the image was cropped after i posted it. I'm a dummy I'm suprised that there ins't a Demon, Apophis or Pharaoh in one of the anons's top rankings though. Fun stuff
(1.24 MB 1148x2110 1113053141.jpg)
>I'm suprised... Lot depends on which anons lurk where. Here we've got a pretty good spread, OP's also the only one with Hellhound in the top 10, though Apophis is in #3 in >>16132. Interesting to see people's strat for also-rans, like Ryu if you prefer Dragon or vice versa. Looks like you and I bump them down a full tier, while >>16273 just left them at #1 and #2. Curious, what about the Wurm appeals to you to put her in #15, and for >>16117 what about Manticore? It's these gals that don't quite fit the type that strike me the most. Or do you just have two types and it doesn't show well in the ranks? That's what I've got, but in my case it's obvious as they war across my entire top 30.
(214.41 KB 467x600 Imp4.jpg)
(258.97 KB 701x580 Lickingfruit2.jpg)
>>16324 I don't get why'd you put Trumpart, Witch, Alice and the Imps in zero. At worst, they're inoffensive.
>>16324 I'm the yeti anon. I had no plan when starting and took it like a blot test. I think i like BIG MEATY HUGS and smug. Manticore is very smug.
(643.19 KB 1523x902 sort-2025-04-20(23_07_30).png)
i like slime :)
(606.21 KB 850x910 2458294642.jpg)
(795.50 KB 1090x892 3652513205.png)
(3.49 MB 2085x2508 2327092898.png)
>>16341 Lolis that act loli don't do it for me and the the Trumpart 'stuck in the card' thing is freaky. Got no problems with other anons who like 'em, but it's my tier list. If I'm fated to pull a flattie in the great monstergirl roulette let it be one of the four in my top twenty.
>>16319 >Hellhound and Manticore on the very bottom, next to furries >all of them below Alps Yeah, it is pretty bold
(259.95 KB 860x814 kotfucker.jpg)
>>16381 >Anubis howls when cumming >Chesh and Jinko loudly purr Anon, your bedroom would be a fucking zoo. Furry accusations would be the least of your worries
(33.42 KB 573x527 1654758389018.png)
>>16366 oh vey, what have the humble nuki done to warrant such hatred? its breathfag, isnt it?
>>16067 Wish the sorter got updated. It's missing some interesting mamono.
>>16381 >Claims not to be a furry >The furries aren't ranked at 230 Hmmmm...
(4.27 MB 1140x2295 my-image.png)
Took me awhile to sort by tier and sort within each tier, but here it is, the definitive tier list. And not just any tier list, but THE tier list. I mean, I do have the best taste in monster girls after all.
>>16445 >Bicorn and Hebi in godtier Interesting choice that one
>>16445 People's lower ranks are the most interesting. Before this I would assume everyone was at worst neutral about slimes and mad hatter.
>>16437 >Spoiler I don't know what that means, I'm just a local.
>>16440 source code is pretty simple, you can try adding it yourself
Btw, the schizo that made the sorter apparently also made this slot machine https://kikasuru.github.io/mge-slotmachine/ You can add up to 36 slots. I dunno why, but its neat you have such ridiculous limit.
>>16456 a shitposter that plagued the /jp/ thread daily for about a year. he would post about how much he wanted to sniff danuki breath and would occasionally comment on other monstergirls breath. this has generally soured most peoples perception of everybody's favorite happy zipanese merchant.
>>16459 Correction, the slot limit seems to be your screen size, so if you make it smaller you can go beyond 200. The possibilities are endless!... I dunno what you'd use it for tho, lel.
>>16459 I GOT DUBS ON A 3 REEL!!! I think the probability is (1/226)*2, which would be around 0,0089. So less than 1%.
>>16459 My math can be off. With 11 slots I thought the math would be (1/226)*10 so around 0.044, so 1 in 23 rolls. But after testing I got 6 dubs in 32 rolls, which is 0.1875, around 1 in 6 rolls. Any probability nerd can help me out?
>>16446 I like to play it dangerous. >>16454 I loathe mushrooms. They're just gross looking and creepy to me, and they taste bad. Hatter is lucky though. She escaped the worst tier. If I was forced to become mushroombrained post-portal, it'd be with a mad hatter. As for slimes, I just strongly prefer a girl with an actual anatomy: heart, lungs, stomach, tongue, eyes, hair, etc. Slimes are just too amorphous for me. I wanna feel her heartbeat as we cuddle, the rising of falling of her lungs as she breathes, feeling her breath on me, soft, silky hair to run my fingers through. I wanna satisfy her with my cooking, filling her belly. Feeling actual skin, the slight imperfections, the hair, sweat, oil, etc. Being able to wipe away the tears, sad or happy.
>>16459 The slot machine one is very outdated. It lacks a lot of the new girls.
>>16445 found the Slapstickstrike enjoyer
(1.65 MB 1278x906 Sandworm5.png)
>>16521 Yes.
>>16460 Oh, that's pretty funny. I've never been to /jp/ so I miss out on a lot of the uber autism. I guess I'm just subconsciously anti-semitic.
(685.81 KB 1518x1341 sort-2025-04-21(08_12_02).png)
Hail Sabbath.
Talk about a contrast, if >>16781 and >>16324 were haremchads they'd split the monster population clean down the middle, with maybe a fight vs. the mofubros >>16273 and >>16132 to claim the softer girls
>>16781 I can hear this man uooing from here.
>>16945 😭😭😭
(3.35 MB 2352x2706 sort-2025-04-23(23_46_12).png)
Terminal foxbrain (pls don't crop)
>>17021 Fuck
>>16324 Something about the manticore just does it for me, might be due to the mongirl dreams one which is a greatly fleshed out character. I think i like mixes of gentle/smug/moron not necessarily in that order.
>>17021 >FOXXED so hard he can't even take a screenshot Rough, buddy. >>17036 Of the few races that can actually accommodate tail sex, nobody, NOBODY can match Manticore in that field.
>>16117 fucking based top 5, cuddlechads stay winning
(10.23 KB 168x300 ikneel.jpg)
>>16067 The sorter takes too long and the tier list doesn't give names I can use to look up the faces I don't recognize.
>>18835 >he doesn't recognize every single mamono by name NGMI
(713.87 KB 1304x910 MGE sorter.png)
>>18835 I came back and did it. Though I rushed a lot of selections because I just wanted to get through so the list seems rather schizophrenic now that I'm looking it over. Several of the girls in the top 11 could have swapped places if I was in a slightly different mood when they were pitted against the other. I'll note that Kikimora only made it into the top 5 because wearing a maid outfit gave her an unfair advantage over the other competitors.
(970.34 KB 1817x1254 Screenshot 2025-05-04 020313.png)
The hell? I only saw march hare like, once, if at all. How is she one of the top? Might need to retake the test later...
>>19226 It's because of how those sorters work. At some point, you tied her with another one of your 1st places. Suppose you tied her with the Yeti. From that point on, every time the Yeti gets matched up again, the real question the sorter is asking you is "Do you like this other girl more than both Yeti and March Hare?".
(4.27 MB 1140x2396 my-image (1).png)
>>19233 Alright, I'll keep that in mind next time. Here have a tierlist that had to be remade on edge because my main browser fucked up the image download
>>19239 only rows i sorted were "God please" and "Fuck off"
>>19239 >Bogey, cow, yeti in top 5 cuddlemaxers once again cannot be stopped
(1.29 MB 2049x1353 sort-2025-05-04(11_00_59).png)
>>19226 Now that's more like it!

[ Return / Catalog / Top ]
Delete
Report