>>33486 i will give her all the good graces i can

>>33247 I'd be fine with 'flayers and 'gaunts if not for the whole thing, really. just don't like it. forced mental changes are also way out of my zone for things I'd actually like to live through. it can be hot in porn but to me? hell nah that's scary I do think it's better when tiers are descriptive. letter grading doesn't really mean anything without a scoring system >>33256 >You seem to generaly like active and straightforward girls guilty as charged panders are big cuties, no idea why no one really talks about em. run-ins with them write themselves, great design, absolutely zero weird stuff. and look at all the fluff >>33486 it is what it is, I'm even less into traps than I am into loli. maybe not less than I am into being a spiderbutt or crotchsquid, but at least a nacho is cute herself. just not something I'd ever want to deal with

I see there's a lot of purple in my top

>>34136 lots of purple and lots of tentacles

>>34136 genuinely the best taste i have ever seen. be proud.

i looked deep within my soul for this one. i've changed a lot since my last one, which wasn't all that long ago. this one feels more correct.

>>34747 looks like there is yet more change in your future

>>34752 what do you mean

>>34753 a large part of your top 10 involves physical transformation or brain chemistry changes

>>34754 in that case i hope youre right

And now, my updated tier list. They're only actively bad when they're in D tier, everything above that is at least okay. Everything in S or above could one-shot me.

>>34902 I understand most of the decisions on F tier, but what about the Kobold and the Cockatrice do you hate. The example kobold looks young, but they can have any bodybuild you like. Also Kej in D, that's a controversial one.

>>34903 For kej, i just don't like hair or the idea of being grabbed by it. It might be beacuse I do housekeeping and have to deal with it a lot, I don't know. Their profile describes it as being sensitive to pleasure, and I find that idea really disturbing. Kobold totally could've gone up a bit, and now has gone up to B after further thought, i've just always imagined them as really dumb and i don't know why. Thank you for helping me see the light. Cockatrice is one of the ones that makes you rape them, and i hate that. i think cockatrice is actually my most disliked out of every monster based off design, usual disposition, and what they actually do.

>>34907 >Cockatrice NTA, she's also quite low in the list for me, but at least she has the decency to turn the tables on me by petrifying, after all that wild goose (chicken?) chase.

>>35127 the petrification is cool but its all they have unfortunately

writing about specific monster girls really improves your opinion on them. who would have thought?

>>36010 Very Solid lineup you have there. I do find it interesting that your top 10 is all straight forward or agressive girls, and then that top 3 is just complete chaos.

>>36010 >zombie that low bweh I like your top ranks though. the dignified hatter among the likes of hellhounds, minotaurs, ogres and horcs is funny writing about mamono involves thinking about them and that builds familiarity with them and that scores them points for sure

>>36028 Straightforward, aggressive and confident is a good combination of traits. There's a fair gap between Hatter/Grem and the rest. Gremlin's inventions and hatter's... everything attract chaos but both are apt at navigating that chaos. Even when things are seemingly going wrong, it's actually all according to plan. >>36031 I wonder if hatter would make ladies out of them, or if they would encourage a far more teasing/dominant side of her out. Anyway, if Ogre is !British (Scottish or northern), then she can bond with hatter over a cup of tea.

The wiki is so slow I can't even look up profiles for the whos I've forgotten about. Go on without me...

>>36127 it's nice and fast in the NA morning hours, at least for a little bit I tried limiting myself to doing it when it worked nice and I had time, but it took too long I guess and the site lost my save, so I just did a tiermaker instead since it's much much faster than a sorter and also gives time for retrospective. I think it's generally more accurate than a sorter

>>36128 I don't know if I have the patience for a proper sort right now so I'm working on a tiermaker, but there are so many monsters I don't think about much and can't just drop into a tier without reading... okay, maybe not all of these, but most.

>he hasn't sorted ms raiju into top tier yet bro...

>>36131 She's been put into row 4. I generally prefer my girls a bit more composed.

I would not be happy with anything below 3

>>36010 great taste! glad to see maneaters so high. hatters cannot be beat, either >>36218 not a bad thing, but youve one of the smallest list of acceptable monsters ive seen. i am a bit confused by malef in 5 but dragonnewt in 0? and dark mage that low?

>>36218 >lamia in 2 >apophis in 6 you love being drugged up that badly? you damn venomslut

>>36010 >>36220 >maneater He put saccophyte at 134 though

>>36220 > You've one of the smallest lists of acceptable monsters I've seen I'm laser-focused on only a few mamonos. I find Dragonnewt far less interesting than Malef. They're maybe more of 1, I will fix that next time. Dark mages are just boring. >>36221 Apo are peak snake, drugs are nice bonus.

>>36223 I don't mind saccophyte, she's got really nice hair and I love green monsters, but triangle teeth short stack brat is acid-induced brainrot.

>>36232 I am more of a saccophyte enjoyer because I like the drowning in aphrodisiac part while I get trapped in the jug with her very up close.

>>36236 I love aphrodisiacs in general. Any girl that has them, a type of venom or pheromones is boosted. Especially pheromones, which is basically what claustro's evaporated acids are. It's why horc is so high on my list as well. I want a girl who messes with my brain and smells/tastes unnaturally addictive. There's something nice about how sacco does it too though. Once you're in, you're stuck soaking in her acids. The close confines of her sack lets her get into some kinky sex positions, submerging you all the way just to get your face level with her crotch. Forced against each other, skin-to-skin friction can't be avoided. The acid rubbed into your skin makes you feel every rub, bump and pinch 100x more. Her jug smothers sensations from the outside, so all you can focus on is her sweet scent, syrupy taste, plump body and crazing eyes. When you're inside, all that exists is you and her. It's a mind melting experience fiting her name. Claustro hits some of those beats, but I headcanon their scent is stronger (as their acid is most effective when breathed in), and I enjoy a smug brat doing that to me.

>>36246 never have i ever agreed with a post more

>>36246 I respect it.

done properly this time, i didnt have any doubt

>>39723 if i saw this list a year ago i wouldn't think it was mine. no way i would've like atlach. an open heart is important.

>>39723 >Large mice in bad. I can understand if you don-ät particularly feel much, but hating them outright?

>>39758 too short :(

>>39758 What if BIG rat?

Something like that. Pretty hard to decide considering that appearance and personalities are not limited by profiles

>>41003 You did remember that Selkies are just regular mermaids with a onesie on top of their tail, right?

>>41020 Are they? >They are also able to freely remove these magical furs, the body revealed being that of a beautiful human woman. When like this, selkies are difficult to tell apart from human women.

>>41003 really good list but why are march hare and jubjub so low? too horny?

>>41059 >too horny? Yeah

>>41030 It's pretty confusing then. >Family: Mermaid. > these seal mermaids wrap their bodies in magical furs >The furs they cover themselves in also, magically, become flush with their skin and move and respond as if they had become part of their body. Guess they are shapeshifters more than anything else. Closer to Doppelgängers than anything else.

>>41063 I think fur is just warm clothing until they get a husband, then it becomes something like a detachable body part

>>41066 Looked them up in wikipedia and my guess was pretty spot on. >Selkies are mythological creatures that can shapeshift between seal and human forms by removing or putting on their seal skin. They feature prominently in the oral traditions and mythology of various cultures, especially those of Celtic and Norse origin. The term "selkie" derives from the Scots word for "seal", and is also spelled as silkies, sylkies, or selchies. Selkies are sometimes referred to as selkie folk (Scots: selkie fowk), meaning "seal folk" >Selkies have a dual nature: they can be friendly and helpful to humans, but they can also be dangerous and vengeful. Selkies are often depicted as attractive and seductive in human form, and many stories involve selkies having romantic or sexual relationships with humans, sometimes resulting in children. Selkies can also be coerced or tricked into marrying humans, usually by someone who steals and hides their seal skin, preventing them from returning to the sea. Such marriages are often unhappy, as the selkie always longs for the sea and may eventually escape if they find their skin. So yeah, they are like that from the beginning, no need for husband.

I finally finished. The profile pictures not being representative and even the size descriptions not meaning much forced me to think about things a lot. Girls aren't sorted within their tiers, and for the sorter I treated kamaitachi A, B, and C as one monster since they're a package deal and mentally filed both youko and inari under "kitsune." I didn't let myself use the tie button. If I did the sorter again I'd probably get slightly different results, so don't mind the absolute sorting TOO much. I also really had to force myself not to think too much and just go with my gut or I never would've finished, the sorter is tough.

>>41141 >filed both youko and inari under "kitsune." You probably shouldn't. Inari and Youko have distinct vibes. The personality and appearance might be variable, but ultimately the profile dictates a determining force in the species personality overall, so you should still weigh them as if they were mostly the profile, even if you can imagine an individual that's the total opposite.

>>41147 >You probably shouldn't I don't see any point. At least the English community rarely bothers differentiating between the two and if the only difference between them is "vibes" when encyclopedia entries don't hard code a girl's vibes (or many other things), calling them different monsters is just sophistry. They're a skill issue apart. Not like I'd bother redoing all of that again for a minor difference anyway. Foxes will remain foxes in my mind.