The sorter seems broken

Didn't know some of the designs got a rework until seeing the tier list.

>>16078 Its not broken And why are you showing a screencap of the old wiki?

That took a while. >>16085 Ah, I thought you had to click on their name to pick one instead of their picture. Doing that takes you to the old wiki.

>>16067 That was kinda fun TBH. I really didn't expect it to turn out the way it did (except for bubble slime.) Each time Yeti came up i just couldn't say no.

those vixen still has an iron grip on my brain. some girls barely came up though. like, i think i saw Lilim and dryad come up once during the entire thing.

>>16132 >>16117 You can select to show images for the top10 btw >>16117 >Alp at 193, not last place Explain yourself slimefucker >>16091 You too geniefucker, you have some nerve to put it above Dragon Zombie and in the same tier as Wight and Gazer.

>>16197 I just don't like the undead.

Did a sorter for the last 10 years (2015-2025) and 6 monsters tied for 3rd place, lul.

>>16197 Lol i didn't know alps were actually dudes in the lore that's hilarious. >tfw still would rather than a literal fucking skeleton, plate mail, cannibal undead, or mosquito if i had to pick. tough decisions require sacrifice. >slimes ranked critically low >Yeti lost in the 100's You're lucky hellhound is in the top ten

>>16203 Slimes are aight, its just MGE ones are boring af. In MonMusu Suu is a really interesting and creative character, MGE is like >here's a pile mucus, have fun Fug that

>lets go through the source code, I wanna see how to make a different sorter >defuq Why are so many programmers mentally ill, yghhhhhh. Slight redemption for calling Kiki best girl, but still, stop being so retarded people.

>>16205 a lot of MGE is just relatively low detail "we snu snu now." with flavor differences. It's when you flesh one of them out with the small details that they become pretty interesting which for example /jp/ did a lot. for example with Dorome. >Gentle loving idiot (top tier personality) >controls mud and earth >causes avalanche in village and destroys a few houses by accident >people want to get rid of her >blacksmith raises hand >wait a second >Dorome makes infinite clay bricks and forges effortlessly while the blacksmith instructs her on the shaping. >makes a lot of mistakes >Bob ross happy little accident >can move through the underground naturally >finds mineral veins in minutes >Villagers love her >She decides she likes the smart human >mud bath coexistence intensifies I had a story in mind where a struggling smith somehow encounters a Dorome and they form a business using her body as a living forge as they travel around. >>16207 eesh

>>16207 H-he's being ironic, right? Just a multi-level joke. >>16200 The older art really does put some at a disadvantage. New mantago is faaar more appealing. Werewolf could really use an update too.

>>16207 The "one of two" sort is retarded to begin with, tiermaker get a ranking with like 100 clicks instead of 1000. That said, >>16209 is right, dueling headcannons are the best part of these threads.

>>16132 >those vixen still has an iron grip on my brain. Y-yeah

...please don't ban me for the bottom ranking. Well, at least now i know for sure i like the softer types

>>16271 >The "one of two" sort is retarded to begin with, tiermaker get a ranking with like 100 clicks instead of 1000. It may take 1000 clicks, but I much prefer it because it sorts in a more objective way. I also don't like dragging hundreds of pictures into boxes, especially because most of them would end up in "meh" tier anyway. >>16295 >...please don't ban me for the bottom ranking. >doesn't show bottom ranks Interesting strats...

>>16282 Well played. >>16300 Agreed that the tiermaker drag is not ideal, much faster if it dumped all girls into the 'meh' tier and after that was "select a tier and then click girls to throw them in it". But that's a UI problem, I'll still defend it as more objective than the 1v1s because you get the final say no matter what. The problem with 1v1s is that even with 1000 choices the tool is still giving you a random subset of the ~20,000 total matchups, and the early rounds are given more weight in this because of how it sorts up or down. If your theoretical third favorite girl comes up against #1 and #2 in those rounds she usually ends up in more like #16 because the tiebreakers can only do so much. It's not likely to be that bad, but the birthday paradox means you're pretty likely to get notable skew, so that while your top 5 might be constant, even your top 20 would differ if you ran it twice. If you don't care about most girls, you also waste maybe 800 of those clicks unless you filter at the start, and if you keep them in for completeness it's probably not great for objectivity in the middle of the pack. Like for me personally, I would not object to a catgirl waifu of most sorts, but Jinko vs. Ocelomeh is so similar that my vote might go either way depending on what else I'm doing, or just non-canon stuff like having seen a nice Jinko greentext more recently. Though I admit even the statistics come out much better if you filter aggressively at the start.

>Interesting strats... ...i only noticed that the image was cropped after i posted it. I'm a dummy I'm suprised that there ins't a Demon, Apophis or Pharaoh in one of the anons's top rankings though. Fun stuff

>I'm suprised... Lot depends on which anons lurk where. Here we've got a pretty good spread, OP's also the only one with Hellhound in the top 10, though Apophis is in #3 in >>16132. Interesting to see people's strat for also-rans, like Ryu if you prefer Dragon or vice versa. Looks like you and I bump them down a full tier, while >>16273 just left them at #1 and #2. Curious, what about the Wurm appeals to you to put her in #15, and for >>16117 what about Manticore? It's these gals that don't quite fit the type that strike me the most. Or do you just have two types and it doesn't show well in the ranks? That's what I've got, but in my case it's obvious as they war across my entire top 30.

>>16324 I don't get why'd you put Trumpart, Witch, Alice and the Imps in zero. At worst, they're inoffensive.

>>16324 I'm the yeti anon. I had no plan when starting and took it like a blot test. I think i like BIG MEATY HUGS and smug. Manticore is very smug.

i like slime :)

>>16341 Lolis that act loli don't do it for me and the the Trumpart 'stuck in the card' thing is freaky. Got no problems with other anons who like 'em, but it's my tier list. If I'm fated to pull a flattie in the great monstergirl roulette let it be one of the four in my top twenty.

I'm NOT a furry

>>16319 >Hellhound and Manticore on the very bottom, next to furries >all of them below Alps Yeah, it is pretty bold

>>16381 >Anubis howls when cumming >Chesh and Jinko loudly purr Anon, your bedroom would be a fucking zoo. Furry accusations would be the least of your worries

>>16366 oh vey, what have the humble nuki done to warrant such hatred? its breathfag, isnt it?

>>16067 Wish the sorter got updated. It's missing some interesting mamono.

>>16381 >Claims not to be a furry >The furries aren't ranked at 230 Hmmmm...

Took me awhile to sort by tier and sort within each tier, but here it is, the definitive tier list. And not just any tier list, but THE tier list. I mean, I do have the best taste in monster girls after all.

>>16445 >Bicorn and Hebi in godtier Interesting choice that one

>>16445 People's lower ranks are the most interesting. Before this I would assume everyone was at worst neutral about slimes and mad hatter.

>>16437 >Spoiler I don't know what that means, I'm just a local.

>>16440 source code is pretty simple, you can try adding it yourself

Btw, the schizo that made the sorter apparently also made this slot machine https://kikasuru.github.io/mge-slotmachine/ You can add up to 36 slots. I dunno why, but its neat you have such ridiculous limit.

>>16456 a shitposter that plagued the /jp/ thread daily for about a year. he would post about how much he wanted to sniff danuki breath and would occasionally comment on other monstergirls breath. this has generally soured most peoples perception of everybody's favorite happy zipanese merchant.

>>16459 Correction, the slot limit seems to be your screen size, so if you make it smaller you can go beyond 200. The possibilities are endless!... I dunno what you'd use it for tho, lel.

>>16459 I GOT DUBS ON A 3 REEL!!! I think the probability is (1/226)*2, which would be around 0,0089. So less than 1%.

>>16459 My math can be off. With 11 slots I thought the math would be (1/226)*10 so around 0.044, so 1 in 23 rolls. But after testing I got 6 dubs in 32 rolls, which is 0.1875, around 1 in 6 rolls. Any probability nerd can help me out?

>>16446 I like to play it dangerous. >>16454 I loathe mushrooms. They're just gross looking and creepy to me, and they taste bad. Hatter is lucky though. She escaped the worst tier. If I was forced to become mushroombrained post-portal, it'd be with a mad hatter. As for slimes, I just strongly prefer a girl with an actual anatomy: heart, lungs, stomach, tongue, eyes, hair, etc. Slimes are just too amorphous for me. I wanna feel her heartbeat as we cuddle, the rising of falling of her lungs as she breathes, feeling her breath on me, soft, silky hair to run my fingers through. I wanna satisfy her with my cooking, filling her belly. Feeling actual skin, the slight imperfections, the hair, sweat, oil, etc. Being able to wipe away the tears, sad or happy.

>>16459 The slot machine one is very outdated. It lacks a lot of the new girls.

>>16445 found the Slapstickstrike enjoyer

>>16521 Yes.

>>16460 Oh, that's pretty funny. I've never been to /jp/ so I miss out on a lot of the uber autism. I guess I'm just subconsciously anti-semitic.

Hail Sabbath.

Talk about a contrast, if >>16781 and >>16324 were haremchads they'd split the monster population clean down the middle, with maybe a fight vs. the mofubros >>16273 and >>16132 to claim the softer girls

>>16781 I can hear this man uooing from here.

>>16945 😭😭😭

Terminal foxbrain (pls don't crop)

>>17021 Fuck

>>16324 Something about the manticore just does it for me, might be due to the mongirl dreams one which is a greatly fleshed out character. I think i like mixes of gentle/smug/moron not necessarily in that order.

>>17021 >FOXXED so hard he can't even take a screenshot Rough, buddy. >>17036 Of the few races that can actually accommodate tail sex, nobody, NOBODY can match Manticore in that field.

>>16117 fucking based top 5, cuddlechads stay winning

>>16067 The sorter takes too long and the tier list doesn't give names I can use to look up the faces I don't recognize.

>>18835 >he doesn't recognize every single mamono by name NGMI

>>18835 I came back and did it. Though I rushed a lot of selections because I just wanted to get through so the list seems rather schizophrenic now that I'm looking it over. Several of the girls in the top 11 could have swapped places if I was in a slightly different mood when they were pitted against the other. I'll note that Kikimora only made it into the top 5 because wearing a maid outfit gave her an unfair advantage over the other competitors.

The hell? I only saw march hare like, once, if at all. How is she one of the top? Might need to retake the test later...

>>19226 It's because of how those sorters work. At some point, you tied her with another one of your 1st places. Suppose you tied her with the Yeti. From that point on, every time the Yeti gets matched up again, the real question the sorter is asking you is "Do you like this other girl more than both Yeti and March Hare?".

>>19233 Alright, I'll keep that in mind next time. Here have a tierlist that had to be remade on edge because my main browser fucked up the image download

>>19239 only rows i sorted were "God please" and "Fuck off"

>>19239 >Bogey, cow, yeti in top 5 cuddlemaxers once again cannot be stopped

>>19226 Now that's more like it!

>>16067 This took a while The tier results should be more accurate. Comparing them one by one is slow and you lose sight of how you ranked them immediately.

>>19328 Extremely correct.

My top three has been the same for a long time.

>>27226 Excellent taste, sir.

>>27226 Hmm, i think i can notice a pattern with this one...

What's the diagnosis doc? Been at least 2 years since I paid much attention to MGE, so I didn't recognise or remember a lot. Tied often and not all make sense to me, Black Harpy should have been grouped with the other harpies for example.

>>27316 Mofubrain, terminal stage. No cure for that one. The black harpy is somewhat distinguished from the average, run of the mill harpy. Highly intelligent, steal shinies, severely agressive if you are a potential mate or a foe, and quite docile if you are a friend. Heavily inspired by crows, as you can imagine.

>>27286 And what pattern would that be, specifically?

Man these things are so hard to do. Somehow I can like A more than B, B more than C, but C more than A. The results become pretty inconsistent depending on the question asked. Wtf is wrong with me.

I redid this several times to get accurate answers and I think this is the best one yet

>>27383 >>27480 If you are struggling with the sorter, i recommend doing the tierlist instead. That way you cansee how you have ranked all of the previous mamono and can compare that to the next one, instead of just vaguely remembering. >>27374 With that top 3, you definitely have a type.

>>27500 >>21085 Yeah, maybe I should've done the tier list instead of having to multi post and delete the others out of shame.

Haven't done one of these in a while and I don't think I've ever done the whole thing. The middle to low rankings aren't very accurate so maybe I should try the tier list one too.

>>27507 I find you should avoid hitting tie at all costs because the sorter will make them both synonymous with each other, making it even harder to see what you're comparing them against. Also, it helps to keep notes on patterns that you might notice with monsters you liked so it helps keep your brain's thought process more consistent.

>>27511 >avoid hitting tie at all costs because the sorter will make them both synonymous with each other Yeah I only hit tie a couple times because I wanted to try running the whole marathon for once, every other time I've done the sorter I just hit tie on all matches I didn't care a lot either way. The top third or half is pretty accurate, but after that there's a lot of girls I don't have strong opinions on so the 1 on 1 rankings get a lot less consistent.

>>27507 Tier list version, it's surprisingly hard to do these even with more direct control than the sorter.

>>27498 I did the tier list, sorted from left to right in each tier, but the tiers don't really have much meaning to them. Also swapped a few monsters around after rereading their profiles.

So many Mindflayers in F tier... So sad...

>>27908 A lot of people seem to hate the transformation part of the abyssals.

how'd I do dark angel does not deserve to be in the dregs, she just only appeared like one time ever my actual monstergirl wife is a wolf but the old MGE design for the werewolf made me click past her a couple times on accident. but the winner does also make sense I wonder what aggregated data would look like. #1 overall is always "everyone's #3-6 or so"

>>27967 Very newbie bait taste anon. Also you may or may not be aware, but the wolfu got an updated design.

>>27908 My reason (I'm >>27682) was a combination of the transformation thing, the messing with your head thing and the body type being a little too wierd (the third might be a misrememberance because it's a long time since seeing a full body image of one). Separately any of those can be ignored or headcanoned and she doesn't really "deserve" to be in F tier, but combined it's too much. The squishyflayers drawn by LN are very cute however, so maybe she could've been a tier or two up just because of that. >>27967 You seem to like the passionate and enthusiastic types. Some might say you like the crowd pleaser races, but a lot of those girls have their popularity for a reason. >I wonder what aggregated data would look like Someone did that five years ago or something, I recall atleast Hellhound and Demon placed very high.

>>27992 I've been around since MGQ part 1's early EN releases though, just not terribly consistently. I witnessed the plansect "everybody wants outta here" apocalypse live and in person I know most of my top 7 are the ones that circulate the most outside of proper anonymous circles, but I just liked that era of MGE a lot. trucker manticore meant I will never stop liking manticores, and I will stand by cheshires and hellhounds being top of the line I will admit I did take a long break from MGE and monstergirl stuff in general. about as long as ~90% EN TL MGQP pt2 and 3's release gap, really. (I blame the many deaths of the jay) so I probably missed out on a large amount of community mindset development around them. I could definitely understand some resentment building up around the more popular ones during my long hiatus I hope the internet monstergirls don't mind me being a crusty old man now instead of a fresh-faced youth >new design it is a huge upgrade and would have gotten proper #1 results. a lot of the older art really struggles to compete with how juicy KCs newer stuff is, but frankly I don't feel like clicking through it again, and the MGE werewolf is not my particular wolfu anyway

>>28015 >passionate and enthusiastic sounds about right if I was forced at gunpoint to pick one specific type, but I do like a variety of qualities. I think what's most important to me is not ending up in a zero-agency "mindbroken and trapped in her hellish pussy-prison I'm forced to breed endlessly" bad end but MGE in general has moved away from a lot of that and towards marriage. in that respect I might have given manticores and a couple others too many wins, but with ~1200 clicks the back half kind of just turns into instinct-driven dick picking hellhound placing high in aggregate doesn't surprise, but demon kind of does

>>28024 Demons atleast back then were super popular, no wonder really with the 10/10 design and how their personalities leave room for alternate takes on the same core ideas.

>>28015 i fully get WHY people dont like mindflayers, i just think people need to expand their minds for lack of a better phrase.

>>28039 that's something a mindflayer would say...

>>28050 I admit I am biased yes

The temptation to press 'tie' is overwhelming but I will resist.

>>27908 I'm >>27745 I don't like the transformation and literal brainfuckery part. That said I'll still take her over tentacles (a dyke), cu siths (furry with absolutely no redeeming qualities), and alps (100% tranny).

>>28107 I'm usually quite anti transformation, but for some reason the squid just seems pretty good. The literal brainfucking is the best part!

Some of these decisions are tough on the soul. Hellhound vs Satyros is so unfair for me and both of them. We should all just kiss i think.

Took me a while to finally finish one. Not hitting tie was a challenge that did irreparable psychological damage to me. I believe my tastes are a mix of unorthodox and absolutely basic.

>>28371 Rare to see the claustros so high? Why do you like them so much?

>>19222 I came back once again, a month later, to do the tier list. This time I read quite a few encyclopedia entries as I arranged them. Notably, Flow Kelp catapulted into the highest tier when I read her profile. As MGE is a marriage fantasy I based the tiers purely on marriage eligibility. They aren't meaningfully sorted within the tiers, I just lined them up the way my autism dictated.

>>28380 i really like close contact and cuddling, i love aphrodisiacs, and i love being restrained. also kind of like being hypnotised.

>>28384 Even if i don't agree, i can understand the reason most choices in the KMS tier. But what the fuck did the sad doot do to you man? >>28388 Surprised not to see stuff like Owl Mage or Taisui higher.

>>28380 Not him, I've placed man eaters high as well but especially saccophytes because on top of this >>28388 I just like it when their looks are deceiving to how much of a predator they are. Gives them an element of mystery to me. I also like quite Taisuis! They're slimes that make you go crazy and yet they act like it's not a big deal. Definitely mysterious.

>>28384 Who the fuck looks at a humanized KELP and goes >Wife ? Well I guess now we have the answer

>>28384 no hate but you are a strange specimen. why would you be ok with imps and devils, but demons and succubi are a no go?

>>28436 not him, but kelps have some appeal. they are super clingy and can change their body based on hydration, thats a pretty big plus to someone with witches and baphomets in high tiers.

>>28371 And now my tier list. Its a little different, but its also correct.

>>28456 >why would you be ok with imps and devils, but demons and succubi are a no go? I've developed strong impressions of succubi and imps over decades of consuming countless hentai games and doujins. Imps are treasures, succubi are scary. Dark Priest is getting nun boosted because evil nun scenes are usually god tier. In retrospect, the succubi in escape could have been put in forced (except Alp, he stays). I was a bit harsh dumping them all in escape next to the slimes. I literally never jerk off to slimes. >>28436 They are ocean monsters (big plus, I like the ocean), they have human legs/thighs, they can shift between loli form and adult form (holy shit!!!), they have long dark wavy hair(kelp) and gloomy disposition, they like piggy back rides, and they can be eaten or used as a cooking ingredient. They're a contender for #1 monster girl.

>>28534 >they can be eaten or used as a cooking ingredient Wtf don't eat your wife

>>28499 Species wise you like many of the same ones as I do, but judging by the rest of the list you aren't very much of a loli enjoyer. Are you sure you aren't missing out?

>>28590 i am very much not a fan, i find it gross. i know theres the whole thing of theyre actually an adult or whatever but its just repulsive to me

>>28597 same anon, i feel the need to clarify that i am a hypocrite because i like the idea of being de-aged/turned into a shota

I shall create a new age to shake the foundations of heaven and earth.

>>29355 the list is so good minus a few things, but why apophis in the lowest tier? :(

>>29394 It's nothing more than a joke. My wife being a Pharaoh as she is, wouldn't enjoy the idea of me putting an Apophis in any other tier. Otherwise, grape snek is fine.

>>29355 Fine taste in high powerlevel girls, I'm a fan of them too.

>>29400 Thanks. Something about a girl so powerful she could crush me, but instead chooses to love me tender is just so wonderful.

>>29402 To be fair the majority of monsters could probably do that

>>29429 nah I can take 'em gimme a werewolf to fight

>>29430 >Mom's basement dweller with a stick >vs >Miss Werewolf, predator of men, hungry for a mate to lead her pack Place your bets

>>29431 excuse me I'll have you know I own several non-wallhanger shit swords

>>29431 >Stick I'm a gentleman who dual-wields and has a respect for the past. It's a stick AND a news paper.

I did the sorter a long time ago, but forgot to post it here. I wonder what my type actually is given the outliers I have.

>>29471 >Candlegeist, armor, automaton, lich and mantis. in the top 10 >but also thunderbird, rata and myconid >and also Aside from Kiki and Nightgaunts being outliers, it's clear what kind of monsters you like.

>>29472 I can kinda see Nightgaunt as the bridge between Thunderbird and Rata and the first category, she's kind of like in between them. I'd argue the Myconid's the outlier... but then I saw Genie and Panda in 11 and 12. Kiki's kinda similar to Automaton too. Mamonos have a lot more in common than you think!